ore IEEE, PTOI July 14,1990 Castlegar News A5 Chamber Luncheon OPINION ESTABLISHED AUGUST 7, 1947 Castlégar News PAGE A4, SATURDAY, JULY 14, 1990 MEMBER OF THE 8.C. PRESS COUNCIL TWICE WEEKLY MAY 6 1 THE MID-WEEK LV. CAMPBELL — PUBLISHER, AUGUST 7, 1947-FEBRUARY 15, 1973 PUBLISHER — Burt Campbell EDITOR — Simon Birch PLANT FOREMAN — Peter Harvey ADVERTISING MANAGER — Wayne Stolz OFFICE MANAGER — Linda Kositsin CIRCULATION MANAGER — Heather Hadiey 1878 AUGUST 27, 1980 EDITORIAL End doesn't justify means Politics in British Columbia, never a pursuit for anyone unwilling to take off the gloves and brawl, took a nasty turn this week after New Democrat justice critic Moe Sihota made public taped cellular g Attorney General Bud Smith. Mr, Smith resigned Thursday amid allegations he attempted to ob- struct justice after the tapes revealed he seemed anxious to damage the reputation of a lawyer Mr. Sihota had hired to prosecute former Provincial Secretary Bill Reid over Mr. Reid’s alleged mishandling of lottery funds. There’s no question Mr. Smith did the right thing in resigning. The allegations are serious and Mr. Smith will now be the subjeet of a police investigation into the allegations. The province could not have an at- torney general operating under such a cloud. But what about the cloud now over the New Democrats? Making public a taped private telephone conversation is distasteful to us to say the least. Monitoring cellular telephone conversations is not illegal in Canada. But taping and making them public is, we think, unethical. The NDP denies it made the tapes, saying the party came about them by other means. But that doesn’t let the New Democrats off the hook. Armed with the information from the tapes, they should have pur- sued the matter in other, more ethical, ways. If the investigation of Mr. Smith finds he acted improperly, then his resignation must stand. If that happens, though, the end still wouldn’t justify the means. VIEWPOINT LETTERS TO THE EDITOR Rebuttal **Whe flings most filth, and wide pollutes around The stream, be his the Weekly Journals bound.”” — Alexander Pope I note with not too little hufhor Mr. Charters’ “‘epistle’’ appropriately shuffled back to his home at Reflections and Recollections. T'must say it took some diligence to locate. I’m happy not to be so disap ited as he, however, and shall attempt to avoid a lengthy litany on the subject of how I feel. I would hold the editor to indulge me awhile, since Mr. Charters’ article seems to beg for a reply. The column, for all its epic grandeur, seems to avoid the point I made in my response to the ist’s rousing tale entitled Time to Sail on Comparisons need adjustment By JOHN MARRITT In a lengthy four-part article en- titled More Than Meets the Eye, Mr. Copeland and Ms. Sherrod of the Valhalla Society attempted to discredit criticism of their organiza- tion’s cross border forest industry comparisons. In support of the contention that the public of B.C. is not getting an adequate return from its public forests, Mr. Copeland and Ms. Sherrod state that ‘‘Americans also realize 800 times more net earnings per cubic metre from the forest.’’ Before people make up their minds on the credibility of such a claim, I hope they will consider that while the U.S. and B.C. publications cited in the Valhalla Society study are both credible, they reflect totally different administrative circumstances and are not comparible without considerable adjustment. The tax systems, the responsibility for access road development and reforestation responsibilities are some examples of why this data is not direc- tly comparable. Making this analysis all the more suspect is the fact that the study makes direct comparisons on U.S. and B.C. data from different * years. The Price Waterhouse analysis of the forest industry economic results during 1989 has just been released. This analysis indicates that forest in- dustry stumpage, current taxes and other payments remained fairly constant at billion. In addition, a further $1.2 billion in income taxes and other payments to governments was made on behalf of employees for a combined total of $2.8 billion. Perhaps Mr. Copeland and Ms. Sherrod were unaware of this economic contribution when they suggested the Americans get 800 times more out of their resource than we do. On the issue of employment, Mr. Copeland and Ms. Sherrod state, ‘‘In the last decade 26,000 forest industry jobs were lost mostly due to moder- nization.”” Statistics Canada data, available in most libraries, suggests this figure is incorrect. The annual census figure for 1979 indicated there were 96,800 people employed in the B.C. forest industry. While the 1989 annual cen- sus figure has not yet been prepared, the Stats Canada monthly survey in- dicates there were 84,500 people em- ployed in the B.C. forest industry last year. While this is approximately 12,000 fewer than at the previous all-time employment peak in 1979, it is essen- tially at the same level which existed before the economic boom occurred at the end of the 1970s. Also, accor- ding to Stats Canada, while there are annual fluctuations, there has been an please see COMPARISONS page AS to governments $1.6 Celgar’s Tide which appeared June 24. It was my impression that this piece prodded a little much: Mr. Charters invoked the ‘‘honorable”’ Brutus who dutifully prophesied ‘‘shadows and miseries” should the ‘‘tide’’ be missed. Mr. Charters venerably echoed the sentiment with a small speech about “‘wise captains’’ and ““delinquent captains,’’ and climaxed with another **incidental”’ tip of the hat to the “‘honorable”’ Brutus intoning ‘‘Like it or not, it is time to close debate and get all hands to readying the ship to sail on the new, the flood it’s tide (sic) we (sic) are all in this boat together and it’s either get on with the job . . .”’ ete. etc. 1 must confess I found myself tasting salt and smelling the sea until | remembered the unhappy fate of Brutus. I found this kind of emotional wrangling rather puzzling and upon reviewing the whole column discovered that it was likely Mr. Charters had decided to help out the company in whom he apparently recognized ‘‘the voice of experience speaking — it’s getting late; the time is now and we need help to get on with the job."” This came as an even greater mystery to me when I realized that Celgar was in the process of doing its second stage review (since the first one apparently lacked “‘snuff’’) and that if they wanted to do it faster, they likely could. Being a vigilant citizen, and smelling rotten fish, I voiced my displeasure to the editor of this paper. I thought Mr. Charters was not playing fair with his readers by using dramatic tones and rustling up what appeared to me to be a stampede to the trough. I felt the people of this area were intelligent enough to decide the merits of the proposed Well, to this Mr. Charters replied with an apparent bombastic fury, scurrying to borrow wit, invoking the name of Christ and Holy Writ, magnifying nits to pick at and, yes, that ultimate, final weapon of pricked pride, the Writer’s Manual. One of Leacock’s characters came to mind: the man who in a frenzy of “doing” jumped on his horse and galloped off in all di ‘at The report was completed, according to the introductions, ‘‘to pressure the federal government to put into practice the principles of sustainable development.”” The convention that elected McLaughlin as leader adopted this task force report and passed resolutions spelling out that the NDP understands once. Lastly, I want to assure the thatI that 1 collapse is i ** But not to worry, the NDP has the answer: “Sustainable conspire with no one and that if after careful consideration of all the facts I find good reason to believe that this expansion is environmentally sound and that it won’t turn this community into a treeless hell, a la Kootenay, I will support it. Paul Maloff Castlegar Use it or lose it What’s that? Lyle Kristiansen doesn’t appear to have read the report of the air tragedy in Cranbrook before making outrageous claims in the press. Why, that would imply that Lyle was seeking to enhance his own image to the voters of Kootenay West-Revelstoke. Tsk! Tsk! And pension day for Lyle so close, too. Isn’t it apparent, with the Celgar expansion hanging fire, that Lyle is busy doing, er, busy, or working on, er, ah, hum working for, about, on or?? I mean Lyle must be very busy, otherwise surely he would be working on behalf of the expansion. Wouldn't he? Perhaps now that Lyle has, it seems, got his seed bins in order he feels that 100 per cent of his time should be devoted to the loss of a few hours of work at the airport. But the truth is, you either use it or you lose it, and without Celgar expansion we won’t need the airport at all. Fred Peitzsche Ross Spur Policy thin Audrey McLaughlin doesn’t like being called an ‘‘ecopornographer.”” Who would? 7 A prominent Canadian Green, David Orton, : capt “‘ecopornography”’ and wrote that McLaughlin and the NDP bought the concept hook, line and sinker. ne flashed off a letter to Canadian expansion on the basis of fact and reliable opinion (that is, with snuff) I also let Mr. Charters know, after a certain fashion, that the practice of revving people up to run hither and tither, with much “‘zeal”’ and little “*knowledge,”’ spurring them on with vacuous slogans like ‘‘get on with the job”’ and “‘it’s getting late’’ was very, very unkind and smacked of Di “prog: ** left-wing denying that she ever bought it. She claims that there is an NDP report titled Sustainable Society which, unfortunately, is not true. The NDP Task Force on Environment produced a report Towards a Future, in is an achievable goal in Canada.”’ Even a cursory reading of the Brundtland report shows that the commission fejects that there could be limits to growth. Its careful assessment of the best that can be accomplished is a doubled human population and five to 10 times the manufacturing of goods as now, with vastly increased energy requirements. Brundtland is a social democrat. This whole concept that it is possible to impose political requirements, (that is, the First World population won’t give up anything, therefore to stabilize the human population a tremendous new round of growth in the Third World is required) on a finite natural system is the result of a failure of the Vision of social democracy. Federal NDP environmental policy amounts to little more than coopting enough environmentalists to hold up a figleaf in front of their solid commitment to the status quo of continued economic growth. This may be fine for political survival but has nothing to do with the survival of the human race, The political task of the 1990s is to figure out how to reduce the impact of human beings on the biosphere and the will to do this can only come from politics that has recognized that the impact is clearly far in excess of what can be sustained now. David Lewis Crescent Valley Please address all letters to the editor to: Letters to the Editor, Castlegar News, P.O. Box 3007, Castlegar, B.C. VIN 3H4, or deliver them to our office at 197 Columbia Ave. in Castlegar. Letters should be typewritten, double- spaced and not longer than 300 words. Letters MUST be signed. and include the writer's first and last names, address and a telephone number at which the writer can be reached between 9 a.m. and 5 p.m. The writer's name and city or town of residence only will be published. Only in exceptional cases will letters be published without the writer's name Nevertheless, the name, address and telephone number of the writer MUST be which the entire second page is taken up by a very large-sized-type definition and explanation of to the editor. The Castlegar News reserves the right to edit letters for brevity, clarity, legality, contempt to me, and for the he professed to ‘‘love so well.”” ** from the Br Commission document Our Common Future. and taste. Members enjoy considerable perks Library blooming nl By JUDY WEARMOUTH ‘Weat has been painting for over 30 years, having started when a workshop on pastel portraiture friend and colleague Dosie Craw- ford. Lately she’s been experimenting with “acrylic ‘watercolor; the beautiful results are hung together, making a great impact. was offered locally, and she still- paints regularly once a week with : Artist Marjorie West displays one of her flower paintings on show at the Castlegar and TOURIST ALERT Comparisons. continued from page A4 increase in forest industry em- {Ey Ployment by nearty 9,000 jobs over the past five years. Mr. Copeland and Ms. Sherrod also point the finger at the export of unfinished forest products in an ef- fort to support the contention that the public isn’t getting its fair share out of the resource. “It is also true that there (the United States), as here, companies are allowed to sell their logs to overseas ‘buyers, who pay nearly double what local mills can pay thus restricting the supply of wood to those local mills,"” they said. “It is nearly criminal that B.C. — whose forests are the .greatest provider of trees on the continent, and one of the greatest in the world — ship so much of its wood to other countries, which get the jobs and the revenue from manufacturing it into products.”” The subject of log exports that Mr. Copeland and Ms. Sherrod raise is an Tourist Alert issued by the RCMP. The following people, believed travelling in British Columbia, are asked to call the person named for an urgent personal message: Gerald Huizinga, Edmonton, call parents in Sidney, B.C. Al and Edith Wiklos, Seattle, call any relative in Seattle. Dale Wuthrith, California, call Bet- ty Giving. Elenor Maley, Vernon, call Wendy Wooigar. Sandra Katscma, Port Coquitlam, call Marjorie Alberten. Betty-Anne Hamilton, St. Stephen, N.B., call Gwen Lawrie. D. Frank Sharpe, Pitt Meadows, call Terry Sharpe. Lorne Julien, Millbrook, N.S., call Edmonton, call Emerson or Lois Janssen, Minoikl, Ill, call Wayne Finnell. Thursday, July 19, 1990 Noon, Sandman inn — GUEST SPEAKER — Preston Mannin National Leader of the Reform Party RESERVATIONS ESSENTIAL © COST $7 Call 365-6313 All Chamber Luncheons are open to the public interesting one. Mr. Copeland was recently quoted in the Arrow Lakes News as saying that the export of logs to Japan and other countries is ‘‘a process which robs B.C. wood- workers of jobs for no other reason than the profits of B.C. logging com- panies.” To put B.C. log ‘exports into per- spective, the percentage of the log harvest exported between 1990 and 1989 inclusive was 3.19 per cent. Last year, log exports had declined to 2.2 per cent of the harvest. People may also be interested to know that ‘log exports from public lands are now subject to a 100 per cent tax on the difference between what the export market and the domestic market will pay for the same creased manufacturing of wood products in B.C. as they appear to be saying, then presumably they would be anxious to see the proposed Ceigar pulp mill expansion go ahead. This x can achieve two objectives that they should support. Firstly, it would make more com- plete use of the chip supply resource im the southern interior. Currently, some chips are not used because no economically viable market exists. Secondly, it would discourage the export of our manufacturing jobs and related revenues to other countries which they describe as ‘‘nearly In closing, 1 would like people to understand just how fragile the ics of the B.C. lumber indus- logs. This tax any to sell logs outside of the province where those logs could be sold domestically. If Mr. Copeland and Ms. Sherrod are genuinely committed to secing in- try actually are what the future could hold. The above-noted Price Water- house report indicates that on lumber sales of $4.6 billion last year there was a net profit of $37 million. This amounts to a return of just under one per cent and 3.1 per cent on capital employed. In spite of this reality, we have Valhalla Society directors, Mr Copeland and Ms. Sherrod, alleging we should be charged higher stum- page rates. That would, of course, make the lumber industry even less economically viable than it is at Present. At the same time, we understand that Mr. McAllister, Sierra Club director, is helping to organize an in- ternational boycott of British Colum- bia wood products. If these two effor- ts are successful, and the lumber in- dustry becomes less economically sustainable, then the economic con- sequences won’t be limited to the lumber industry and will touch everyone in our resource-dependent Southern Interior communities. There is in fact “‘more than meets the eye.”” Please think about that. John Marritt is president of the In- terior Lumber Manufacturers Association. Tourism is going places. Get going with... Selkirk College ri Careers Training Now accepting applications for the 8-month programs in: RECREATION & RESORT OPERATIONS & MANAGEMENT FOOD & BEVERAGE MANAGEMENT & OPERATIONS PROFESSIONAL COOKING LEVEL 1 TRAVEL AGENT A partner in Tourism Educalion with the Pacific Rim Institute of Tourism learn more, contact: Admissions | Office - Nelson Campi 2001 Silver King Road, Neison, B.C. V1L 1C8 (604) 352-6601 eal °F state WITH BARRY BROWN LOCATION — ‘LOCATION Choosing the best location for a home is probably the most difficult decision a buyer must make (other than the choice of the home itself) But answers to a few questions by family members should make the decision easier | suggest that the family answer the following questions betore deciding where they would like to live and the type of home they would like to buy 1) Is the distance to your place of employment an important con: Are the city's jant to 4 YEARS AGO From the July 13, 1950 Castle News The Castlegar Public Library Board met at the home of Mrs. C.H King last Thursday afternoon with Mr. J.A. Charters in the chair, and members Mrs. E. Hopland, Mrs. R. Whittaker, Mrs. C.H. King, Miss A.C. Bloomer and Secretary- Treasurer Mr. W. Markin present. . . The first official telephone call in Castlegar was made by Mr. J.R. SUN LOVERS c Me ae ig T-SHIRTS & SHORTS fp. POOR BOYS Elliott, President of the Castlegar & District Board of Trade, from the telephone banquet to the Honorable A.D. Turnbull, Minister of Health & Welfare, Victoria. Mr. Turnball had just returned to Victoria that morning after officiating at the opening jes of Mt. (The former Robson _resident’s Property was expropriated by B.C. Hydro.) . Strong recommendations that Kin- naird ‘‘make arrangements for adequate and effective standby Saint Francis in Nelson. 25 YEARS AGO From the July 15, 1965 News Fred Pressacco yesterday announ- ced settlement of his dispute with B.C. Hydro. He ‘said he received a wire Tuesday r of Hydro’s offer of $12,500 and yesterday sent a wire accepting it. He would make no further com- ment. pumping rather than relying on the use of river water in the case of any extreme emergen- cy,”” has been made by medical health officer Dr. Nick Schmitt. 15 YEARS AGO From the July 17, 1975 Seven hundred and five hourly rated CanCel employees are out of work here — 325 at the pulp mill and 380 at the sawmill — as a regplt of a strike by the Pulp, Paper and Wood- workers of Canada. ~> Vandalism at Pass Creek Park will leave a permanent loss to the residen- ts. Regional Recreation Commission No. 1 director Pat Metge told the Castlegar News a lifeguard chair, signs and some of.the benches have been put ablaze, now > and ) tt would be. one or more members ot family must rely on public tran. sportation, bus or car pool for get ting to work, schoo! or play ts the family more city or more suburban and: rural oriented? It sometimes proves difficult to oc climate yourself to a style of living you are unfamiliar with. If rural is © consideration, will the family require an extra car? Is someone prepared to take youngers mem. bers to and from work or recreation facilities? call or'drop in ot 1695 Columbia A; families might f change your home's si: te Of decor but not its location 3) Would the family be unhappy with ‘only a small plot of land surroun ding the home, or does it need a quarter acre or more’ cultural advantas your tamily? Soi | “deprived If hour or more museums. libraries or cultural centers hurches and enough for 5? you can always appearan Wf there 1s anything | can do to help ycu in the hield of real estore please INRS NATIONAL REAL ESTATE SERVICE Mountainview Agencies Ltd. ve Phone 365-2111 or 365-2757 there isyno way financially of replacing them. 5 YEARS AGO From the July 14, 1985 Castlegar News Expansion of the Westar pulp mill in Castlegar is one of the investment possibilities suggested in a com- prehensive report released this week analyzing forest products industry and forestry resources in the Central Kootenay. Province of British Columbia Notice to B.C. Consulting Engineers and Technicians R.I.S.P. REGISTRATION UPDATE The Ministry of Transportation and Higftways is updating its register of consultant engineering and technical companies, firms and individuals capable of delivering professional engineering services to the Ministry under contract. (R.1.S.P. System) Services typically required include Electrical Engineering CENTRAL FOODS SPECIALS Sunday, July 15 to Wednesday, July 18 WHOLE CHICKEN =:-::... CHICKEN LEGS ==::<:.. CHICKEN BREASTS ==. CHEESE SLICES :=:::..-~ DINNER BUNS......... WHITE BREAD ....2.. 0100. ..u. FRUIT WEDGES.......... COOKED HAM oocc. cx occco nance POTATO SALAD........ 218m 99° 2m 99° 5m 52.69 s00c.°3.39 voz. °1.29 550 G. 99° 3 ror? 1.00 100 G. 17° 100 6. 39° MARGARINE... CUBED ICE... ORANGE JUICE... cso con 541m 91.18 COKE or SPRITE s::0:.. 652.98 zx. Victona. B.C. V8W 3E6 FRESH PRODUCE poise ~ Toe fhone” 387. 1tt or 387-7079 CARROTS...... $1.48 F plus Scotchguard paca ean upon request. KIWI FRUIT NEW TEALANO 4/$1 00 rc WATERMELON... 40m 18 Standard gineering choir & regrstration package. Technical Services registration package or both when making your We reserve the right fo mit quantities Prices limited to stock on hond 3-LB. PACK 5] .89 98° Editor’s note: Members of Parliament and the Senate receive numerous benefits on top of their salaries and tax-free allowances. But the perks don’t match what's available in the private sector. By GERRY ARNOLD OTTAWA — First-class air travel, dining room and a private health club. Sound like the kinds of perks one might expect for directors of a top private corporation? In fact, they're just-a few of the benefits-at the Senators get $9,600 annually tax-free for expenses, “disposal of every member of Parliament and senator. Plus about $153 # day in expense money just for showing Granted, life as an MP has a lot of hassles. ve But it’s not all bad, either. How many Canadians unwind after a hard day at work by having a sauna and rub-down from the company masseur? Pent-up parliamentarians can. They just head for the health club in the Confederation Building down the street from Parliament Hill. Don’t try visiting the club — it’s off-limits to all but the elected and appointed. Tain Angus, an NDP member from Thunder Bay- Atikokan, chuckles when asked about MPs’ pay and perks. People, he says, will complain no matter what “People’s attitudes, well, it comes with the job,” h is the parliamentary restaurant, on the sixth floor of Weicwuc’ Carpet & Uphotstery Cleaners Parliament's ornate Centre Block. Coupon Special MPs, senators, senior civil servants and journalists $5.00 DISCOUNT dine at tables draped in fine linen cloth. They sit under the high, soft-colored ceilings which arch into domed E skylights. One side of the an is pocked with alcoves for ON CARPET CLEANING more private conversations. OF $45.00 oR MORE! The price is right, too. The luncheon buffet, for wT oaons OMCOUNT example, is $9.50 for a spread fit for a king. A couple of parliamentary cafeterias offer more spartan surroun- dings. There's more. Two barber shops charge $6 for a haircut, and a shoe shine goes for $1. There are a beauty salon and five post offices where MPs and senators mail and correspondence free: There are a tailor shop, locksmith, a drycleaner and a ~— On the other hand, the" mentary liquor store is one of the few places on the Hill where things cost more than outside in the real world. It charges 50 cents more per item than regular outlets, to discourage staff from shopping there. Gerry Arnold is a writer with The Canadian Press says. ‘‘If we were only making $30,000 a year total and we asked for another $5,000, we would still get a lot of criticism."’ For the record, MPs and senators earn about $62,100 each. MPs get an extra $20,600 in tax-free expense allowance, and they soon may get another $6,000 tax-free annually to offset the cost of keeping a residence in Ot- tawa. OK, so the money’s not really great for a member of Parliament. But there’s more than money involved. Travel, for example. MPs each receive 64 return airfare trips a year, first class, to or from anywhere in Canada. Their spouses can also fly free, and other family members are allotted some free travel as well. Senators receive the same amount of free travel but have more restrictions on who can use it. Further, every MP, senator, spouse and dependent child receives free passes for untimited travet on Via Rail. Cabinet ministers have a fleet of Challenger business jets which they can use instead of commercial airlines. And to get to the airport, cabinet ministers don’t need to bother with cabs. They have chauffeur-driven cars which line up outside the various Parliament buildings, -often waiting for hours with the engines running. In all, there are more than 100 chauffeur-driven cars on the government tab, with an annual cost in excess of $800,000. For those members _lacking-a -chauffeur-driven car, there’s a network of free buses to ferry them around the sprawling Parliament Hill complex. The buses drop MPs off near their cars, which are parked free on the Hill. Where does everybody go when they get into their cars? Well, a favorite place for MPs and senators to meet Traffic Engineering Highway Planning Drafting Services Ngineering and Technical based firms and companies are invited to apply an exclusive for registration by contacting: RISP System Administrator Ministry of Transportation and Highways James King, president of Hay Management Con- sultants in Toronto, says the perks that MPs and senators receive pale by comparison with those available to private-sector executives. eomve “In comparing MPs with jobs of the same size in the private sector, they are underpaid by a significant amount,"’ said Kirig. He suggested in a 1989 report that MPs and senators would earn salaries of about $78,600 in the private sector. 7 That report said a cabinet minister now earning about $110,000 in straight salary would make from $190,000 to $390,000 for the same private-sector respon- sibilities a furniture shop, a chestertield request Living & dining room, 3 bdrms This 1s a call for expressions of interest only. pannel for future contracts will be based upon noo ares } CENTRAL FOODS ‘OPEN SUNDAYS Community Owned & 10a.m.-6 p.m 2717 Columbia, C SS